In which situations is a Marine expected to exercise judgment and initiative?

The expectation for a Marine to exercise judgment and initiative is most critical during combat operations and unforeseen operational challenges. In these high-stakes situations, the environment is dynamic and can change rapidly, often requiring quick thinking and the ability to adapt to new information or unexpected circumstances.

Combat scenarios demand that Marines assess their surroundings and make tactical decisions that can impact the mission's success and the safety of their fellow service members. Similarly, unforeseen operational challenges—whether they relate to logistics, terrain, or enemy tactics—also necessitate a flexible approach, as established protocols may not apply.

While routine maintenance checks are essential for operational readiness, they generally involve following established procedures where initiative is less critical. Strict protocols are designed to ensure consistency and safety, leaving little room for individual judgment. Similarly, direct orders provide clear guidance that doesn’t usually require the exercise of personal initiative. In contrast, the unpredictable nature of combat and operational challenges creates a context where judgment and initiative are vital for effective decision-making and mission accomplishment.